Controversy Between Gay Marriage
Based on the two articles read, “Speaking Out: Why Gay Marriage Would
Be Harmful”, by Robert Benne and Gerald McDermott, and “Who Cares If Gays Marry?”, by Gregory Blair both have a different perspective when it comes to the theme of gay marriage. One of these articles, “Speaking Out: Why Gay Marriage Would Be Harmful”, demonstrates factors that are mostly prejudice. They are discriminating against different people’s way of life when it comes to choosing a partner of the same gender. On the other hand, “Who Cares If Gays Marry?”, is an article that informs us that there shouldn’t be any difference with other people and their choices of partners, that marriage shouldn’t always be a woman and a man.
In the article, “Speaking Out: Why Gay Marriage Would Be Harmful”,
it informs the readers of the components that contribute to harming current and future heterosexual marriages, such as, bad for marriage, children, and society. All of these categories are affected in various ways. “The concept of marriage necessarily includes the idea of a man and woman committing themselves to each other. Any other arrangement contradicts the basic information.”(Benne and McDermott 300)
First of all, the definition of marriage doesn’t
usually have to include a man and a woman, what matters is that they both respect each other and are capable of agreeing when conflicts arrive between them. The differences are what join them together to become stronger as one.
“Gay marriage will change marriage more than it will change gays.”
(Benne and McDermott 301) Troy Perry told The Dallas Morning News that fidelity is living in an honest relationship and looking out for one another, but due to varying options people comment around that committed couples sometimes have more than one sexual partner. There has been a research made in the Netherlands and they came to the conclusion that in homosexual relationships they have an average of about eight partners per year outside of their one mate relationship. The author says that if we agree to gay marriage then the role model that they will play will be letting others believe that it is okay to have more than one partner at a time while being married. In other words, they are setting the example of infidelity which would not be the correct example of a marriage.
Second, children become affected by this situation
they might begin to get bullied in school because they have parents of the same gender. In other cases they even begin to feel uncomfortable with their own gender because they fear that they will inherit or have the same preferences as their guardians. Even though there are some problems that children face, as well as not getting to know one of their biological parents there are also they good factors that contribute. When two people of the same gender cannot have kids or aren’t capable of doing so they can always adopt children or receive sperm donations. These children run a good probability that they will get molested within the family and have homosexual experiences themselves.
Third, it seems that gay marriage can affect society, too.
Not only is it a struggle to be able to keep marriages together, but with gay marriage it will make things more complicated. People believe that gay marriage will ruin the lives of true Americans. “Let us keep the definition as it is, and strengthen our capacity to live up to its deals”. (Benne and McDermott 303) They believe that the definition of marriage should remain as one man and a woman that there is no room in society for individuals that prefer their own gender as mates. The idea of gay marriage will ruin how Americans are viewed throughout the world.
In the article of, “Who Cares If gays Marry?”, by Gregory Blair, he describes
the definition of a marriage, God, and against American values.
In the definition of a marriage,
“Other cultures around the globe; many of them have different variations of what constitutes a marriage.” (Blair 307) The author, in other words, is making the point that in a marriage it doesn’t really matter what kind of preferences you have. That in other countries there are marriages where there might be one husband and a multiple number of wives. Also that in other places there have been people of the same gender that have been married and that they haven’t made it that big of a deal that they are accepted just the way they are. “The word ‘marriage’ itself is not discriminatory…and neither should we be.” (Blair 307)
When it comes to the theme of God
Blair believes that it is alright to believe in our own beliefs, but that doesn’t mean that we should use the government to enforce the law. After all there are different ways that gay marriage is interpreted and not all of us take it the same way. There will always be different views in this matter.
“It is meant to equally prevent people from being persecuted
or discrimated against because of their beliefs.” (Blair 308) The author gives a reason that no one should be treated differently because of their choices in partners. Everyone has the freedom and liberty to be with whoever they decide to be with. The ideal protects homosexuality form being a sin and it can be an acceptable lifestyle. It is not hard to try to understand other customs or point of views from other peoples.
In conclusion the article that best uses evidence would be
Gregory Blair’s, “ Who Cares If Gays Marry?” He goes into detail and proves his points based on what the facts are and what people may not know about gay marriage. Blair makes all of his argument strong enough for readers to understand his point and where he is coming from between the debates on gay marriage.